Olanzapine is more effective than lithium against mania and similar to lithium as long-term maintenance for bipolar disorder
The antipsychotic agent olanzapine is significantly
more effective than lithium in delaying relapse into mania and as
effective as lithium in long-term maintenance of bipolar disorder,
according to a presentation at the Annual Congress of the European
College of Neuropsychopharmacology. The investigators suggest that
success with this class of drugs may enable psychiatrists to focus
on long-term wellness rather than treatment of acute episodes.
Patients with bipolar I disorder who had
at least 2 manic or mixed episodes within 6 years and a YMRS total
score > 20 received open-label therapy with olanzapine and lithium
for 6 to 12 weeks. The 431 patients who met symptomatic remission
criteria were randomized to double-blind monotherapy for 52 weeks
with olanzapine (217 patients) at doses of 5 to 20 mg daily or lithium
(214 patients) titrated to a therapeutic serum level of 0.6 to 1.2
mEq/L at doses of 300-1800 mg daily.
Patients on olanzapine had a significantly
lower incidence of relapse into mania than patients treated with
lithium (14.3 percent versus 28.0 percent). Rates of relapse into
a depressive episode were very similar (16.1 percent versus 15.4
percent). Among patients who relapsed while on monotherapy, time
to relapse for 25 percent of patients in each group was 380 days
for olanzapine and 212 days for lithium. The incidence of hospitalization
for a bipolar episode was significantly lower with olanzapine than
with lithium (14.3 percent compared with 22.9 percent).
Additional findings related to quality of
life while on monotherapy. The rate of drug discontinuation due
to adverse events was 18.9 percent for patients on olanzapine and
25.7 percent for those on lithium. Significantly more olanzapine
patients (46.5 percent) completed the 52-week trial than lithium
patients (32.7 percent). Weight gain was the major adverse effect
of olanzapine: Weight gain across the open-label and double-blind
phases of the study was significantly greater for olanzapine than
for lithium (1.79 kg average and 1.38 kg average, respectively).
"Prolonged maintenance allows patients
to gain greater control of their lives without the severe devastation
and disruptions that bipolar mood swings can cause," said Eduard
Vieta, M.D., Ph.D., study investigator. "As our understanding
of this complicated condition has evolved, we have learned that
treatment needs to be more than a response to acute episodes and
should focus on stabilizing the patient’s condition to prevent relapse
over the long term. These data indicate that olanzapine is a promising
choice to stabilize moods, as it prolongs periods of wellness."
|