Patients
treated for depression only with antidepressant medication are more
likely to be dissatisfied with care
Patients who
are treated for depression primarily or only with antidepressant medication
are more likely to be dissatisfied with their care, according to an
article in the February issue of the American Journal of Managed Care.
The American researchers, led by Leif
I. Solberg, M.D., assert that their findings, taken over a 3-month
follow-up period, emphasize the importance of education, counseling,
and psychiatric referral as components of health care plans drawn
up by primary care physicians.
"They [the patients] seem relatively satisfied with the courtesy
and respect shown to them, but there is considerable room for improvement
with satisfaction with choices of treatment, the ease of getting
help, or seeking specialists and follow-up care," said Solberg.
Almost 78 percent of the 274 patients in the
study received a prescription for antidepressants, and 94 percent
of those prescriptions were filled. A much lower proportion of patients,
roughly 33 percent, reported that they were given educational recommendations
or support materials.
The patients, mostly white and female, were
given a survey 1 week after their initial diagnosis of depression
and 3 months afterward. The survey contained questions on doctor
visits, prescriptions, other therapies, and their general health
status. Investigators also compared the patients' survey answers
with information in their medical records.
All patients had access to mental health counselors
at their primary care clinics as well as off-site, full-time psychiatric
services, and both services were available without a referral from
their primary care physician. However, only half of the patients
who were notified of their diagnosis reported they had received
a recommendation to see a mental health professional.
In addition, few patients had multiple follow-up
visits with their doctor, and many patients reported that they had
stopped taking their antidepressant medication during the 3 months
after diagnosis.
Although patients' average scores on depression
tests improved slightly over the 3 months of therapy, their "relatively
low level of satisfaction with depression care or feeling able to
get the help needed for their depression remained unchanged,"
said Solberg.
|