Risk
for development of Type II diabetes differs significantly among antipsychotic
agents
A large-scale
records review suggests that the risk for developing Type II diabetes
varies widely among antipsychotic agents, with the highest risks associated
with olanzapine, clozapine, and high-potency and low-potency conventional
drugs, according to an article in the October issue of the Journal
of Clinical Psychiatry. The American
researchers studied records for patients with a reported diagnosis
of psychosis drawn from an insurance database with a total of over
2.5 million people. Patients with psychosis and a diagnosis of Type
II diabetes made up to 8 months prior to psychiatric observation
were excluded. Records for 4,308 patients diagnosed with psychosis
who received at least 60 days of antipsychotic treatment between
April 1, 1996, and Dec. 31, 1997, were compared to 3,625 patients
who received no such therapy.
The risk associated with use of clozapine
was the highest for any of the antipsychotic medications: It was
more than seven times that of patients who were not given antipsychotic
medication (7.44). The degree of risk for olanzapine and low-potency
conventionals was similar, at somewhat more than three times that
for no treatment (3.10 and 3.46 respectively).
The risk for a high-potency conventional agent
was roughly double that of the risk for patients in the no treatment
group, at 2.13. Interestingly, the risk for risperidone, an atypical
antipsychotic agent, over 12 months of treatment was not significantly
different from the risk for untreated patients.
"Diabetes is a serious, life-threatening illness that can lead
to heart failure, stroke, renal failure and blindness," said
Henry Nasrallah, M.D., one of the study authors. "Treating
schizophrenia is complicated enough without adding diabetes to the
equation."
"This study is based on [insurance] claims data, and thus is
subject to the usual limitations of retrospective research. That
includes not being able to control for some variables that may have
affected the outcomes, such as race and changes in weight,"
said Frank Gianfranceso, Ph.D., lead study author and president
of a pharmaceutical outcomes-research firm. "Diabetes is an
important issue for patients with mental illness, and further research
is certainly needed to better define the risks related to particular
treatments. However, the findings of this study are very similar
to several other publications and add to the growing body of information
practitioners should consider as they choose among the various treatments
available to their patients."
|