The
updated Bethesda system for Pap smear results divides certain categories
into finer ones with more clinical significance
The newly updated Bethesda system for reporting of Pap smear results,
termed the 2001 Bethesda System, has been published in the April 24th
issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association. Roughly
50 million Pap smears are done annually in the U.S. as the primary
or sole screening test for cervical cancer.
The 2001 Bethesda System does
not include guidelines for clinical management of cases in which
abnormal results are found. However, the system serves as the basis
for new management guidelines that appear in a companion article
in the same issue of the journal. The clinical guidelines were developed
under the sponsorship of the American Society for Colposcopy and
Cervical Pathology in tandem with the work done to create the 2001
Bethesda System.
Publication of the two papers
is considered a milestone in efforts to improve cervical cancer
screening. "Together, Bethesda 2001 and the Society guidelines
should provide more uniform, evidence-based care of women with cervical
abnormalities," said Diane Solomon, M.D., who coordinated development
of The Bethesda System at the
National Cancer Institute.
Bethesda 2001 updates the earlier
Bethesda System, first published in 1989 and revised in 1991. The
2001 version reflects the most current knowledge about the biology
of Pap test abnormalities and addresses new screening technologies
that have appeared in the past decade.
There are three key areas of
change in the revised system: sample adequacy, terminology for atypical
squamous cells that are associated with an increased risk for a
premalignant lesion, and terminology for benign cellular changes.
The Bethesda System has always
required the smear interpreter to evaluate the adequacy of cervical
cell samples based on a standard set of criteria. The 2001 Bethesda
System incorporates criteria that are specific to the new thin-layer
or liquid-based cell collection method now used by many American
doctors.
The older Bethesda System grouped
all squamous cells considered equivocal ---that is, atypical but
not clearly precancerous --- into one category known as atypical
squamous cells of undetermined significance, or ASCUS. The Bethesda
2001 System adds a new category for atypical cells that have a higher
risk of association with premalignant lesions: "atypical squamous
cells -- cannot exclude a high-grade lesion" or "ASC-H."
By highlighting such cases,
the new system should help physicians detect and treat
precancerous lesions more rapidly. In addition, the term "atypical
squamous cells favor reactive" has been eliminated in order
to focus greater attention on women at higher
risk of an epithelial abnormality.
The previous version of Bethesda
included a category of "benign cellular changes" to communicate
findings due to a variety of factors (namely, inflammation). However,
this approach occasionally caused confusion for clinicians who questioned
whether the term indicated negative results or the need for follow-up.
Now such benign changes are more clearly identified as "negative."
In addition, The Bethesda 2001
System recommends that laboratories report use of computerized scanning
of Pap test slides or use of molecular assays such
as tests for human papillomavirus.
More than 90 percent of laboratories
in the United States use The Bethesda System, as do laboratories
in many other countries. To date, more than 20 national and international
societies have endorsed Bethesda 2001.
|