Exercise training program
better than beta-blockers at improving outcomes in Postural Orthostatic
Tachycardia Syndrome
An exercise training program worked better
than a commonly used beta blocker, significantly improving - even
curing - patients with a debilitating heart syndrome, according
to research published in Hypertension: Journal of the American Heart
Association.
Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS) - called "The
Grinch Syndrome" because most patients have a heart that's
"two sizes too small" - affects about 500,000 Americans,
primarily young women.
POTS is characterized by a rapid increase in heartbeat of more
than 30 beats per minute or a heart rate that exceeds 120 beats
per minute when patients change from lying down to standing within
10 minutes. The heart rate is high with palpitations, but the stroke
volume and blood volume are low. Symptoms include dizziness, lightheadedness,
fatigue, chronic orthostatic intolerance and occasionally fainting.
POTS may be life altering and may cause substantial disability that
interferes with daily living. In the United States, women who are
afflicted with POTS range in age from adolescence to about 50.
In the small study, 18 Caucasian women (average age 27) and one
man completed the double-blind drug trial. They were randomized
to receive either the beta-blocker propranolol or a placebo for
four weeks followed by three months of exercise training. There
were 15 age-matched healthy controls, 14 women and one man.
In analyzing quality of life, researchers found:
- All patients completing exercise training showed improvement
in physical function scores.
- Nearly all patients completing the exercise program (95 percent)
showed improvement in social function scores.
- All patients completing exercise training showed improvement
in heart rate responses. Ten (53 percent) of 19 patients were
"cured" of POTS - that is, their change in heart rate
with standing no longer met criteria for the syndrome.
- Aldosterone-to-renin ratio increased among those in the exercise
program. This ratio is low in POTS patients, and it remained low
after the beta-blocker treatment. Aldosterone-to-renin plays a
critical role in how the body handles changes to blood circulation
during prolonged standing.
In an analysis conducted prior to beginning the exercise regimen,
researchers found the group receiving beta-blockers showed no change
in social function scores and very few patients improved physical
function scores.
"The exercise training program is a resounding success in
the treatment of POTS," said Benjamin Levine, M.D., senior
study author and director at the Institute for Exercise and Environmental
Medicine at Texas Health Presbyterian Dallas.
"The unique component is to start training in a recumbent
position, which is important to those who can't tolerant standing.
This strategy avoids the upright position that produces symptoms.
We don't even let patients stand up to exercise for one or even
two months," said Levine who is also professor of medicine
and cardiology and distinguished professorship in exercise science
at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas.
"However, to maintain the benefits these patients will need
to incorporate the training program into their everyday lives indefinitely."
Typical recumbent or sitting exercises include cycling with a recumbent
bike, rowing and swimming. The exercise training progressively increases
in intensity, duration and frequency. Training begins with 30- to
45-minute sessions, two to four times per week. By training's end,
patients are exercising five to six hours per week and encouraged
to exercise upright.
"Exercise training is superior to the beta blocker in restoring
upright blood circulation, improving kidney function and dramatically
improving quality of life," said Qi Fu, M.D., Ph.D., study
first-author and assistant professor of internal medicine and cardiology
at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center.
Researchers are conducting a similar study in a community setting
outside the constraints of a controlled clinical trial. They also
have initiated a POTS registry that includes detailed instructions
for physicians to conduct the exercise-training program.
Other co-authors are: Tiffany B. VanGundy, M.S.; Shigeki Shibata,
M.D., Ph.D.; Richard J. Auchus, M.D.; and Gordon H. Williams, M.D.
Author disclosures are on the manuscript.
The National Institutes of Health, the National Space Biomedical
Research Institute and the Clinical and Translational Research Center
funded the study.
|