JPAD Trial: Low-dose aspirin did
not significantly lower atherosclerotic events in type 2 diabetics
Type 2 diabetics treated with low-dose aspirin did not
have a significantly lower incidence of atherosclerotic events than those who
received placebo in this primary prevention trial of low-dose aspirin, according
to research presented at the American Heart Association's Scientific Sessions
2008. However, sub-group analyses showed a significant reduction with aspirin
in both atherosclerotic events in those over 65 years of age, and a reduction
in cerebrocardiovascular deaths.
Results from The Japanese Primary Prevention of Atherosclerosis
with Aspirin for Diabetes (JPAD) trial were presented as a late-breaking clinical
trial. The study was simultaneously published in the Journal of the American Medical
Association.
"Our results indicate that aspirin is effective and safe
for primary prevention of cardiac and cerebrocardiovascular death in diabetics,"
said Hisao Ogawa, M.D, Ph.D., lead investigator of the study and a professor of
cardiovascular medicine at Kumamoto University, Kumamoto, Japan, and chief of
the division of cardiology at the Kumamoto University Hospital. "In addition,
it offers a low-cost approach."
The randomized trial included 2,539 type 2 diabetics at 163 Japanese medical centers.
Researchers observed a positive trend for a reduction
in all atherosclerotic events in the aspirin group (20 percent relative risk reduction)
for the entire population, but it did not reach statistical significance. Atherosclerotic
events include coronary heart disease death, fatal stroke, non-fatal myocardial
infarction, unstable angina, exertional angina, non-fatal stroke including transient
ischemic attack, and peripheral arterial disease.
In a subgroup analysis, the researchers found an association
between daily low-dose aspirin use and a 32 percent reduced relative risk for
all atherosclerotic events, both fatal and non-fatal, but only for diabetics over
age 65. In other words, individuals over age 65 who took aspirin had a hazard
ratio of 0.68 compared to those who did not take aspirin.
During an average of 4.4 years of follow-up, 154 atherosclerotic
events occurred, both fatal and non-fatal (68 in the aspirin group, 86 in the
non-aspirin group.) Those events included one fatal cardiovascular event (a hemorrhagic
stroke) in the aspirin group and 10 fatal strokes or heart attacks in the non-aspirin
group, Ogawa said.
Researchers found a large, statistically significant
risk reduction for fatal coronary and cerebrovascular events in the aspirin group
vs. the non-aspirin group (hazard ratio of 0.10.) But the confidence interval
on that finding was wide (CI=0.01 to 0.8), indicating a need for further study,
he said.
Aspirin therapy is commonly used for primary prevention
in diabetic patients in the United States and Canada, but not in Japan, Ogawa
said.
Several earlier studies have established the benefits
of aspirin therapy in preventing second cardiac events. However, its use for primary
prevention in diabetics has been controversial because of the lack of data indicating
benefits and because aspirin carries a risk of gastric bleeding, Ogawa said.
He said aspirin was well tolerated as demonstrated by
the comparable number of the combined endpoint of serious hemorrhagic events (hemorrhagic
strokes and major gastrointestinal bleeds).
In comparing bleeding events, the researchers reported
13 hemorrhagic strokes, with no statistically significant difference between aspirin
takers and non-takers (six such strokes in the aspirin group; seven in the non-aspirin
group).
On the other hand, the total number of all hemorrhagic
events was greater in the aspirin group compared to the non-aspirin group (34
vs. 10 such events). Four patients in the aspirin group had bleeding events that
required transfusion. Furthermore, those in the aspirin group had more gastrointestinal
symptoms (55 cases vs. eight cases), but all cases were resolved without surgery
and no fatalities occurred, he said.
"Our findings need to be interpreted in the context of
the low incidence of atherosclerotic disease in Japan," Ogawa said. "We conclude
that aspirin as primary prevention is beneficial at least for fatal heart attack
and fatal stroke in our entire study group and for all atherosclerotic disease
among those age 65 or over."
Co-authors are: Masafumi Nakayama, M.D, Ph.D.; Takeshi
Morimoto, M.D, Ph.D.; Shiro Uemura, M.D, Ph.D.; Masao Kanauchi, M.D, Ph.D.; Naofumi
Doi, M.D, Ph.D.; Seigo Sugiyama, M.D, Ph.D.; and Yoshihiko Saito, M.D, Ph.D.
The study was funded by Japan's Ministry of Health, Labour
and Welfare.
|