SIMPADICO Trial suggests immunomodulation reduces C-reactive protein but does not significantly improve function in patients with peripheral arterial disease
Immune modulation with Celacade appears to
reduce chronic inflammation underlying peripheral arterial disease,
significantly decreasing C-reactive protein levels, but it does
not appear to significantly improve function in these patients,
according to results of the SIMPADICO Trial presented at the annual
meeting of the American College of Cardiology.
SIMPADICO was a phase III trial in which
947 patients were screened for eligibility and 553 adults were randomized
to Celacade or placebo. Although patients in the active arm not
reach the primary endpoint of change in maximal treadmill walking
distance, Celacade significantly reduced high sensitivity C-reactive
protein (hs-CRP), a pre-specified endpoint and a widely recognized
marker of systemic inflammation.
"We are obviously disappointed that
Celacade was not shown to improve walking distance in peripheral
arterial disease, one of the most difficult endpoints in which to
demonstrate a therapeutic benefit," said Jeffrey Olin, MD,
principal investigator and presenter of the study. "It is very
interesting to note, however, the finding of a significant reduction
in C-reactive protein, a well recognized inflammatory marker that
is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular events."
Measurement of hs-CRP was included in SIMPADICO
as a pre-specified endpoint to assess impact on systemic inflammation.
The mean levels of hs-CRP at baseline were well matched at 4.15
mg/L and 4.81 mg/L in the placebo and Celacade groups, respectively;
these levels are consistent with a patient population at moderate-to-high
risk for cardiovascular and peripheral arterial disease events.
Mean hs-CRP was reduced by 0.93 mg/L in the Celacade group, while
it increased by 0.50 mg/L in the placebo group. A majority of patients
were on anti- platelet therapy (82.1% placebo, 77.5% Celacade),
predominantly aspirin, and were receiving lipid-lowering therapy
(81.3% placebo, 79.8% Celacade), predominantly statins, which are
known to reduce hs-CRP levels in cardiovascular conditions, providing
evidence that Celacade significantly reduces hs-CRP levels on top
of anti-inflammatory pharmaceuticals.
The modified intention-to-treat population
(535) that was used for primary data analysis consisted of all patients
randomized who received at least one study treatment and had at
least one post-randomization treadmill test. The placebo (273) and
Celacade (262) groups were well balanced for all important baseline
characteristics, including demographics, maximal treadmill walking
distance (absolute claudication distance, 321 meters placebo, 303
meters Celacade), smoking history, comorbid medical conditions,
and medications.
The percentage increase in absolute claudication
distance between baseline and 26 weeks was not significantly different
between Celacade and placebo groups. Similarly, there were no significant
differences in the pain-free treadmill walking distance (initial
claudication distance) between groups.
In a time-to-first-event analysis, 84 patients
experienced a peripheral arterial disease-related or cardiovascular
outcome event during the course of the study, 46 in the placebo
group and 38 in the Celacade group. In a similar analysis of only
peripheral arterial disease-related outcome events, 20 patients
experienced an event, 14 in the placebo group and 6 in the Celacade
group. Fifteen of these patients progressed to critical limb ischemia,
12 in the placebo group and 3 in the Celacade group, a significant
difference.
While changes in quality of life and ankle-brachial
index did not reach significance, exploratory analysis in the per-protocol
group (patients with no major protocol violations and who received
a pre-designated number of treatments, 416) showed significant changes
in several measures.
Quality of life analysis (SF-36, v2), showed
a significant difference between Celacade and placebo in the Physical
Functioning and Social Functioning Scores. On the Walking Impairment
Questionnaire, Celacade was also associated with significant improvements
in the Distance and Speed domains. There was also a small but statistically
significant improvement in ankle-brachial index at 26 weeks in the
Celacade group.
Celacade was shown to be well tolerated in
this patient population, who were receiving standard-of-care medications
for atherosclerosis and peripheral arterial disease including statins,
beta-blockers, anti-platelet agents, and angiotensin converting
enzyme-inhibitors.
|