What
is Diastolic Heart Failure and How Should I Treat It?
William
H. Gaasch
Lahey Clinic, Burlington, Vermont, USA
Although
dozens of large-scale clinical trials have been conducted evaluating
treatment of patients with heart failure due to impaired left
ventricular systolic function, none has evaluated treatment
of heart failure due to left ventricular diastolic dysfunction.
Many patients develop heart failure due to left ventricular
diastolic dysfunction, and it is important for physicians to
understand the phenomenon and to learn how to diagnose and treat
patients who develop the condition.
Dr. Gaasch showed a very dramatic slide: On the left side were
listed the names of about twenty large-scale, randomized, double-blind
studies of treatments for patients with heart failure due to
left ventricular systolic dysfunction. On the right side, the
column was labeled "Diastolic Dysfunction" but there
was only blank space beneath the label. In fact, relatively
little attention is given to this problem in the medical literature
and among clinicians. Dr. Gaasch reviewed the European Cardiology
Societyユs definition of heart failure due to diastolic dysfunction.
The definition requires the presence of all three of the following:
(1) signs and symptoms of congestive heart failure, (2) normal
or only mildly abnormal ejection fraction, and (3) evidence
of diastolic abnormality.
Dr. Gaasch described a study he and his colleagues had conducted
at his institution, the Lahey Clinic. They performed an echocardiography
and cardiac catheterization correlation study, performing both
studies in 63 patients who had congestive heart failure, normal
left ventricular volumes and ejection fractions, and evidence
of increased left ventricular wall thickness -- that is, left
ventricular hypertrophy. The researchers found abnormal diastolic
filling pressures and prolonged relaxation times, including
prolonged isovolumic relaxation time and prolonged deceleration
time, in these patients. Overall, all of the patients had abnormal
diastolic function and 94% had at least one pressure and one
echocardiographic abnormality. Dr. Gaasch concluded: "In
congestive heart failure with left ventricular hypertrophy and
a normal left ventricular ejection fraction, the diagnosis of
diastolic heart failure can be made via demonstration of diastolic
abnormalities on echocardiography, without cardiac catheterization."
Dr. Gaasch then described two very small studies of treatment
of heart failure secondary to diastolic dysfunction, each involving
approximately 20 patients. One used verapamil as the study drug,
and the other used losartan. The results of the studies demonstrated
improvements in exercise capacity and Quality of Life and decreases
in congestive heart failure score. Two treatment studies are
currently underway, one investigating candesartan and the other
perindopril. Dr. Gaasch concluded: "In these patients,
treat the hypertension, because in these patients, hypertensive
left ventricular hypertrophy is apparently the primary underlying
cause of the failure. However, if a patient presents with symptoms
of heart failure, first treat those symptoms -- donユt think
about the etiology. Then, if the patient has coronary artery
disease, he should undergo revascularization. If he has hypertensive
heart disease, treat the hypertension."
Reporter:
Andre Weinberger, MD
Copyright
2000-2013 by HESCO International, Ltd. All rights reserved.