The Rationale for Combining Medications in the Management of Bipolar Disorder

Frederick K. Goodwin, MD
George Washington University
Washington, DC, USA


The complexity of bipolar disorder suggests that combination therapy will lead to more effective treatment of this disorder. Combination therapy may lead to synergistic mechanisms of action. For example, clinical and basic research indicate the action of lithium and the anticonvulsant, divalproex, act synergistically in their beneficial effects. Greater compliance is reported in patients receiving combination therapy with lithium plus divalproex compared to monotherapy with either drug. Other treatments for bipolar disorder are also discussed.

The great majority of data on the efficacy of putative mood stabilizers in bipolar disorder is derived from monotherapy studies. The research community and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) prefer monotherapy trials. Monotherapy trials have provided valuable information on individual drugs. However, the complexity of bipolar disorder suggests that combination therapy will lead to more effective treatment of this disorder.

In actual practice, most bipolar patients receive more than one medication. Combination therapy allows the clinician to target different symptom clusters such as cognitive, psychotic or increased psychomotor activity in mania. In addition, combinations of drugs may lead to synergistic mechanisms of action.

Lithium has been the standard treatment for patients with bipolar disorder. Current research indicates the most effective mood stabilizers to use for prophylactic treatment of bipolar disorder are lithium, divalproex, lamotrigine, carbamazepine and olanzapine. Prophylactic treatment of rapid cyclers is achieved with lamotrigine, divalproex, carbamazepine and lithium. However, for rapid cyclers, prophylaxis of depressive recurrence with lithium is preferred over prophylaxis with antidepressants. Breakthrough depression is best treated with lithium, lamotrigine, olanzapine. Some reports indicate successful treatment of breakthrough depression with divalproex, while others do not.

Dr. Goodwin mentioned the importance of realizing that many signal transduction pathways may be involved in the biological cause of bipolar disorder. As a result, not all bipolar patients are the same. For example, some manic patients may respond to lithium while others may respond to depakote.

New research investigating the mechanism of action of lithium and the anticonvulsants suggest that lithium and the anticonvulsant, divalproex, act synergistically in their beneficial effects. This would further suggest that combination therapy with lithium and divalproex is more effective when used together. The dose of each drug used is below the dose used in monotherapy. This information supports the recent report that compliance is greater in patients receiving combination therapy with lithium plus divalproex compared to monotherapy with either drug.

 


Reporter: Andrea R. Gwosdow, PhD